How The Chicago Red Stars Became The Epitome Of NWSL Dysfunction

When Brooke Elby came upon in 2018 that she were traded from the NWSL’s Utah Royals to the Chicago Red Stars mid-season, she wasn’t certain what to anticipate. Chicago used to be going again on a prior business in some way, in a triangle of offers transferring Sofia Huerta and Taylor Comeau to Houston and Christen Press to Utah—all after the Red Stars had despatched Press into exile in Sweden upon agreeing to a prior business with the Dash that had led to the striker to go away the league fully. 

In the small global of girls’s skilled football, gamers had been additionally usually conscious about the struggles that their colleagues had been having with Chicago head trainer Rory Dames, together with an reputable criticism that Press and others had dropped at U.S. Soccer in 2014 and 2018, announcing Dames had emotionally abused and manipulated gamers. Elby knew about Dames’s recognition for having a mood, however nonetheless she packed up her issues and waited for phrase on her subsequent steps. 

What Elby were given to start with from her new membership used to be silence; she didn’t listen from the Red Stars for twenty-four hours. She needed to monitor down a telephone quantity herself and reached out to the crew to get a flight booked to the Midwest. She used to be fortunate that her school teammate Summer Green performed for the crew on the time and may just in my opinion pick out her up from the airport. 

Green then drove Elby to the non permanent housing Chicago had put in combination for her: a Holiday Inn in La Grange, Ill. She stayed within the resort for days, whilst being informed that Red Stars majority proprietor Arnim Whisler used to be exploring choices for her housing. She interpreted the tone loud and transparent: Despite together with her for price within the business, Chicago used to be completely unprepared for her to if truth be told display up.

Elby discovered a spot to stick during the generosity of U.S. girls’s nationwide crew midfielder Morgan Gautrat, who had just lately returned to the NWSL after a stint with Olympique Lyon in France. Elby were in La Grange for greater than per week when Gautrat presented her a spare bed room within the brief time period. The two get on well, and Elby would stick with Gautrat and her husband for the remainder of the season—in a development owned via Whisler.

“He owned the properties,” Elby stated. “He would come try to fix things, or he would be bringing furniture over or doing things like that.”

This used to be a ways from the one factor that appeared unprofessional to Elby as soon as she joined the Red Stars. And this factor, like others she skilled, all appeared to hint again to the way in which Whisler ran the membership. 

Whisler will not be a family call, however he’s been a key determine in skilled girls’s football in the usfor neatly over a decade. He’s owned the Chicago Red Stars for the reason that Women’s Professional Soccer league folded in 2012, then shepherded the crew into the upstart NWSL the place they won a name for secure performances.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYhr-nWCr1g

Fans knew Whisler as a personable presence, each in particular person and on social media. He used to be readily to be had to banter on Twitter and might be observed giving toasts within the car parking zone of the crew’s stadium at pregame tailgates, speaking to lovers about participant performances, or even hinting at long term roster strikes. In a still-growing league, the can-do perspective in Chicago appeared to supply a buffer for a loss of assets in different spaces.

But the crew’s luck lined up numerous issues inside the Red Stars that more and more couldn’t be defined away via the standard increasing pains of a brand new league. 

As a ways again as 2017—neatly earlier than the Washington Post broke the tale about Dames in November 2021—Elby and 3 former staff who spoke to Defector stated that Whisler dismissed issues dropped at him about Dames’s conduct. On Oct. 3, the investigation via Sally Q. Yates discovered that Press’s criticism about Dames in 2014 were shared with Whisler, who in reaction stated that participants of the U.S. Women’s National Team sought after “this league to shut down” and easily had an “axe to grind” with Dames. In September 2021—after The Athletic reported on former gamers who stated then–North Carolina head trainer Paul Riley had sexually coerced them, resulting in Riley’s firing in addition to shedding his training license—a subset of recent traders requested Whisler about issues that they had heard immediately from gamers about Dames, in line with a supply as regards to minority possession. Whisler, in step with the supply, downplayed their issues.

(Dames’s legal professional didn’t go back calls or emails from Defector in search of remark. Dames didn’t remark at the authentic Post tale however, in a observe up about more than one accusations of abuse via Dames in adolescence football, his legal professional despatched the newspaper a commentary denying the allegations and accusing the newspaper of “damaging and destroying” Dames’s recognition.)

Whisler’s blind spots went past Dames’s conduct. Whisler by no means pretended to be the richest proprietor in NWSL. But past the price range, his paternalistic idealism of a crew of gritty underdogs punching above their weight permeated all of the membership, in accordance to people who witnessed it—which positioned gamers and team of workers in hurt’s means.

Defector spoke with a complete of 13 individuals who had been or are involved with the crew, together with more than one former staff. Many of them described an atmosphere through which Whisler persisted to act as though the NWSL had been nonetheless a small mom-and-pop league on the point of chapter, with the entire unhealthy and even unhealthy conduct that include that mindset. He joked concerning the crew’s loss of a human assets division. He supplied the most cost effective foods imaginable for his gamers and handiest on sure days of the week. His crew automatically lacked elementary assets and amenities for gamers, in line with Elby. 

Those who labored for Whisler described him as aloof, and from time to time inept in his makes an attempt to micromanage the crew’s price range. According to former staff, he informed them to stick inside of crew places of work all the way through fuel leaks. The housing he supplied for gamers integrated flats he owned, making him now not handiest their boss however their landlord. Minority traders raised issues about the ones housing stipulations after you have participant comments. 

And Whisler used to be informed time and again about Dames. 

Defector despatched the Chicago Red Stars an inventory of greater than 20 questions in addition to a request for remark in this tale. In reaction, the crew despatched the next commentary: “We continue to encourage players and staff to share their experiences to inform the ongoing joint NWSL/NWSLPA investigation and further shed light on past club and league failings to help inform how we rebuild the culture of our organization and create an environment where players and staff feel safe and supported.”

The commentary went on to mention that the crew had taken steps to strengthen participant housing, together with plans to transport gamers into impartial housing all the way through the offseason earlier than final with “we remain committed to making investments in best-in-class resources for the team and to giving our players the full support they need to be successful on and off the field.”

Defector additionally reached out immediately to Whisler, who didn’t reply to any emails, calls, or textual content messages asking for remark. However, Whisler did talk with the Yates investigators with reference to Dames. He informed them that there used to be “nothing to this day” that he noticed or used to be informed about Dames that can have been interpreted as abuse or misconduct. He additionally stated that he used to be “never provided a full readout of the breadth of the allegations against Dames nor provided any findings related to the investigation prior to The Washington Post article.”

The membership’s recognition exploded in past due November 2021, quickly after shedding their 2d NWSL Championship in as many seasons. The subsequent day, Dames impulsively resigned at 11:54 p.m. CT, not up to 24 hours earlier than the Post revealed a document filled with testimonials from former Red Stars gamers who described abusive training practices via the membership’s supervisor of 10 years. Quite a lot of gamers had requested to go away through the years because of their remedy, and that want were granted in selections made via each Dames and Whisler. 

Then got here the Yates document. In reaction, the crew’s board of administrators voted to take away Whisler as chairman of the board. On Oct. 10, the present gamers of the Red Stars issued a commentary of no self belief in Whisler. “We are united with the Board of Directors in their decision to remove Whisler from the organization entirely and look forward to finding a new majority owner who can help us realize the full potential that we as players always knew existed for this club,” the commentary learn.

Actions have already been taken to a great deal restrict Whisler’s affect, however the technique of doing away with him as proprietor may just turn out trickier. As detailed because the Yates document used to be, former staff who spoke to Defector stated that there have been issues that the document can have long gone into much more element concerning the Red Stars, a membership they described as formed via normalized unprofessionalism and toxicity. 

A supply as regards to the crew in 2019 didn’t get the impact that Whisler’s intentions had been essentially unhealthy, however that he approached the crew with a paternal intuition because of the years and cash he’d spent ensuring the crew existed in any respect. 

“He almost made it seem like you should be grateful for what you have now,” the supply stated, “even if you think it’s not enough.” 


As defined within the Yates document, it’s inconceivable to split the historical past of the Red Stars from Dames’s position as trainer and basic supervisor. Dames used his connections as a adolescence trainer in Chicagoland to scout skill, and the membership additionally benefited from drafting locals who had subject matter off-field beef up as they attempted to navigate making the crew. Dames started his occupation with the Red Stars as a volunteer, depending on his recognition because the president of Eclipse Youth Soccer, then turned into a contractor who didn’t take a lot of a wage. Per the Yates document, no due diligence used to be performed earlier than hiring him. Even because the NWSL grew, Dames persisted his position with Eclipse Youth Soccer all the way through his occupation with the Red Stars.

With Dames on the helm, Chicago had various outwardly a hit seasons at the discipline, with top-four finishes in six-straight seasons, one Cup ultimate, and two championship ultimate appearances. With stars like Press, Sam Kerr, Yuki Nagasato, and Julie Ertz at the crew’s roster over time, the squad’s luck contrasted with the chaos gamers needed to handle at the back of the scenes, and it got here with a value. 

Throughout Dames’s tenure, submissions to the NWSL damage document got here with a way of gamesmanship, now not all the time giving a transparent image of which gamers had been suffering with lingering problems as they carried heavy mins, and from time to time even misrepresenting dips in shape. “Rory got very lucky that we had some amazing women who played through pain or didn’t get hurt very often,” Elby stated. He additionally managed nearly all the float of conversation to gamers, which made them depending on him, in step with the Post. 

Then-head coach Rory Dames of the Chicago Red Stars before a game between Chicago Red Stars and North Carolina Courage at Sahlen's Stadium at WakeMed Soccer Park on August 15, 2021 in Cary, North Carolina
Rory Dames (Photo via Andy Mead/ISI Photos/Getty Images)

Favored gamers needed to lift heavy mins because of Dames’s loss of rotation and agree with in his bench, in line with Elby. Meanwhile at practicing, substitutes from time to time wouldn’t even have interaction with Dames, separated utterly from the beginning XI. Dames coached with a transparent hierarchy, with key starters protecting courtroom—from time to time even main tactical adjustments, Elby stated.  While gamers by no means let it grow to be an issue between them, the adaptation in remedy between starters and reserves used to be all-encompassing, extending into weight room scheduling, restoration precedence, and even simply precise training pointers via the technical team of workers. Players who weren’t tagged to make the 18-player roster on away days wouldn’t go back and forth with the crew, and reserves would cross into practicing dreading being handled as an afterthought.

According to each Elby and previous staff with wisdom of operations previous to 2021, there have been years when Dames would wait till practicing the day earlier than away journeys to call his touring celebration and, as a result of Whisler would now not pay to go back and forth gamers now not at the bench, gamers must pack for video games with out figuring out if they might if truth be told be making the shuttle. The cheapness prolonged to flights themselves: Multiple former staff take into accout Whisler the usage of gamers’ and coaches’ loose checked luggage in keeping with their very own Premier Status to test crew tools like ball and jersey luggage without cost.

Dames would even be very explicit about how he sought after the locker room arrange on gameday, and would blame team of workers in the event that they didn’t line the gamers up in the right kind order, with starters on one aspect and substitutes at the different, in line with two assets. On no less than one instance, he moved tools round himself to ensure starters had been sitting in line with his approval, in line with a former worker who helped with gameday setup. 

Without a transparent hierarchy to respond to to—as Dames used to be additionally basic supervisor—team of workers would in finding themselves stuck between trainer and proprietor from time to time, nearly all the time at the price of their psychological well being. At least one former worker used to be left in tears via Dames because of errors made via miscommunication, and then Whisler would ask his head trainer to ask for forgiveness however would take no additional motion. A unique worker described the daily swings as “you never knew what you were going to get with Rory.” 

“He’d defend Rory to anybody,” Elby stated. “He knew everything Rory did. And if he didn’t know firsthand by seeing it, he knew because every player was in that office at some point telling him.”

Whisler informed the Chicago Sun-Times and Yates that he had no advice from U.S. Soccer in 2018 to take away Dames from his position as each basic supervisor and head trainer, and that the entire issues dropped at him through the years by no means warranted swift motion. But merely because of the closeness of the group and the way in which Whisler wove himself into gamers’ lives, from time to time performing as their boss and landlord, Elby stated she idea it needed to be inconceivable for Whisler not to know what used to be occurring. Many humans echoed this sentiment within the Yates document, with more than one former gamers announcing there used to be no means that Whisler didn’t know, in addition to recounting his “axe to grind” feedback from 2014. The document additionally said that again in 2013, “Whisler himself reported to [then–NWSL executive director ] Cheryl Bailey that a player had raised ‘concerns about Rory.’” (Whisler does now not explicitly deny this within the Yates document, which stated that Whisler additionally informed Bailey that the similar participant used to be the usage of her issues to get extra money and the crew used to be “aggressively exploring trades within the league for her.”)


In the Yates document, former Red Stars defender Sam Johnson stated that her business to the Utah Royals got here suspiciously quickly after a gathering she had with Whisler complaining about Dames’s remedy of the crew. A former worker stated they suspected that Johnson wasn’t the one participant to have that have; Whisler and Dames all the time had believable football causes for strikes, or that they had been honoring requests, however the timing between proceedings and trades used to be noticeable to the staffer. 

“He’d defend Rory to anybody. He knew everything Rory did. And if he didn’t know firsthand by seeing it, he knew because every player was in that office at some point telling him.”

Brooke Elby

A unique former worker remembered one assembly with Whisler in 2018. They knew about Dames’s recognition as a adolescence trainer via assembly former Eclipse gamers of his, in addition to unhealthy studies different entrance workplace team of workers had with him at practicing. 

“When we’d meet someone who’d played for Rory as a kid, our response would be, ‘I’m sorry,’” they stated.

Alarmed via various cases of front-office disorder, the team of workers member requested for a gathering in August 2018. Whisler pushed aside one explicit tale—that Dames had given a adolescence participant an consuming dysfunction—to the team of workers member as outdated, and named Red Stars that Dames had excellent studies with up to now as a counter-argument to what used to be going on on the skilled stage, the previous worker recalled.

Another former worker described Whisler as each aloof and a bit extraordinary from time to time, and but any other felt he steadily had his “head in the clouds.” One former staffer stated he operated with a “white-knuckle death grip on the past,” and an overbearing focal point at the Red Stars as a blue-collar workforce that punched above their weight. A fourth former worker recalled that Whisler would comic story about Dames running without cost, in spite of the pinnacle trainer making $108,000 a yr via the tip of his tenure on the membership, in line with the Yates document.

This perspective manifested in some ways. Even after Elby performed with the Red Stars, Whisler used to be nonetheless speaking about hiring a human assets administrator. Before then, any individual with issues used to be meant to document them to an assistant trainer. According to a former worker, Whisler would comic story with team of workers concerning the HR division that he knew didn’t exist, whilst crossing the road into asking staff—various whom had been younger girls—about their sexualities and courting lives whilst ”trapped in his workplace, which is a windowless room.” (Whisler denied this in his interview for the Yates document, which stated that Whisler informed them “the only context in which he would ask about an employees’ relationship status would be if he heard concerns that the employee was involved in an inter-office relationship involving a subordinate or superior.”) 

Two different former staff additionally recalled a tradition through which assistant coaches would sign up for gamers and team of workers at native bars after video games in 2018 and 2019, with a tradition of consuming in combination, which might result in beside the point feedback. A former worker additionally remembered Dames creating a flippant remark in 2018 about now not talking to her on my own, lest he be investigated once more.

Many staffers, like gamers themselves, started running for the crew proper out of faculty, and the Red Stars had been their first revel in in skilled sports activities. Unprofessional conduct then turned into normalized, as devotion to gamers stored them on the membership so long as they may stand to stick. Staff had been presented uncompetitive salaries via Whisler for years, grew to become down for raises, and now not supplied healthcare till 2020, a number of former staff stated. On one instance Dames even weaponized an worker taking a greater process, telling gamers on her behalf right away after a nasty postseason loss, in line with a former worker. 

For the gamers, the Red Stars’ folksy recognition for doing so much with a bit if truth be told translated to what Elby noticed as constant sub-par remedy for gamers as neatly. After having post-training foods looked after ceaselessly in Utah, her new membership informed her that they just had cash to pay for meals on sure days of the week. Former staff say that Whisler wouldn’t pay for catering supplied via Chicago’s stadium because of charge, choosing chains like Chipotle and Potbelly as an alternative. Players would deliver their very own supplementary pieces, mixed with what the crew supplied: “a blender that worked half the time, and protein powder for days,” Elby stated.

Brooke Elby #23 of Chicago Red Stars dribbles with the ball against the North Carolina Courage at SeatGeek Stadium on July 21, 2019 in Bridgeview, Illinois.
Brooke Elby (Photo via Quinn Harris/Getty Images)

Elby remembered disruption within the daily as they performed 2d mess around to the Chicago Fire, who had been the transparent precedence on the Bridgeview practicing facility on the time. Red Stars gamers didn’t have get right of entry to to the amenities’ weight room, they usually needed to defer in scheduling, inflicting practicing occasions to be moved on the drop of a hat, Elby stated. On go back and forth days, the crew can be placed on more than one flights at strange hours to economize on flight tickets, putting additional pressure on their our bodies. 

The public is used to tales of athletes in girls’s sports activities sacrificing for the larger excellent, coping with unfair remedy as younger leagues growth. But Elby felt what she skilled in her time there used to be explicit to the Red Stars, and led from the highest via Whisler. 

“For what you expect as a professional athlete, it was a joke,” Elby stated. “To already come in knowing your team is the poorest team out there isn’t a great feeling. Because we already know everything we’re going to get is going to be like a downgraded version of what everybody else has.”

Elby retired from skilled football after the 2019 season, largely on account of her studies with the Red Stars. In vintage NWSL model, phrase had gotten round. 

“It’s not a feeder team, it’s a ‘you stay there for the rest of your career’ team,” she stated. “The stigma that comes with Chicago: You are on that team from the day you get drafted to the day you retire. The only reason this team and these players are so successful is because they have such a good mentality, and a family within the team.”


In addition to proudly owning participant housing, Whisler would additionally from time to time act as belongings supervisor, from time to time even solving issues himself in an try to economize. One specifically infamous development in Chicago’s Ukrainian Village had a transformed area—with no door—designated as an additional bed room in line with Elby, who stated she and Gautrat additionally had a unit with kitchen air flow problems. She described a blurring of the work-life stability, as Whisler turned into omnipresent in gamers’ lives.

A former worker recalls the method of putting a participant who joined the crew mid-season in considered one of Whisler’s flats, and the conversations that went on between proprietor and team of workers about get ready for her arrival. The crew made certain that elementary facilities had been met, but if team of workers prompt little touches like supplying recent cleaning soap or freshly laundering sheets when they arrived, Whisler stated that gamers are adults and will do the ones issues themselves. Other staff remembered being passed “hundreds of unmarked keys” to sift via to in my opinion let in locked-out gamers, and that they’d be the primary humans referred to as to make things better in participant flats. 

In 2020, the NWSL started a year-round housing mandate, forcing groups to allot extra in their price range towards ensuring their athletes had a spot to are living of their house markets. Team housing within the NWSL, as showed via the collective bargaining settlement ratified in 2022, is meant to paintings considered one of two tactics: Either a participant can decide in to team-provided housing this is absolutely paid for via their membership, or they’re given a money stipend to spend on hire in different places. The housing and car spending cap, become independent from the league’s wage cap, has been supposed to lend a hand groups complement residing bills in markets the place gamers aren’t creating a supportable salary.

But in Chicago, it’s nonetheless unclear what the precise monetary courting is between the crew and Whisler as a landlord, or how Whisler has offset prices inside Chicago’s housing price range up to now. A front-office worker who used to be supplied housing via the membership in 2017 described a procedure the place Whisler set a unit’s hire in keeping with the worker’s instances (in the event that they had been relocating, as an example). Prior to 2020, Whisler would additionally rate sure gamers some hire to are living in his flats, in line with two former staff. The crew extensively utilized host households for gamers via no less than the 2019 season.

When Defector reached out to the Red Stars for remark, the crew gave the next commentary in reaction: “We believe it’s imperative to change the current state of our player housing. Earlier this year, the board took measures to improve conditions of the player apartments and the property management, as well as initiated plans to move players into independent housing during the offseason. We also recently offered all players immediate housing options and accelerated the plan for relocation in the offseason.”

While Whisler’s door used to be all the time open, Elby stated gamers didn’t all the time really feel they may cross to him, even for problems unrelated to Dames; if he conceded on one level that might charge cash, he’d must make concessions in different places.

The membership’s bodily workplace area may be in a development owned via Whisler. Multiple former staff take into accout fuel leaks whilst running, all the way through which they had been informed to not go away the premises whilst a technician used to be referred to as. Whisler had put in cameras in any respect workplace entrances and exits, making staff really feel they may now not go away with out him figuring out.


The 2020 Challenge Cup highlighted different stressors for gamers. The Red Stars roster had a visibly splintered reaction to the taking part in of the nationwide anthem following the homicide of George Floyd, and defender Casey Krueger used to be left in tears at the league broadcast earlier than their opening fit. After that sport, Dames refused to let gamers be made to be had to the media. 

Behind the scenes, the Yates document discovered that Dames had resorted to racist name-calling. No dates are given within the file, however some of the allegations within the Yates document used to be that Dames would name gamers from Ohio and Kentucky “trailer trash,” referred to as black gamers “thugs,” and referred to 1 black participant as am“bodyguard.” (Dames declined to be interviewed for the Yates document, as an alternative offering them with a commentary that the 2018 investigation via the USA Soccer had “cleared him of any misconduct” and denying any abusive conduct.) 

This wasn’t the primary time this factor with Dames were introduced up publicly. In tweets she later deleted, the league’s first-ever draft pick out, Zakiya Bywaters, wrote in 2016 about Dames the usage of the remark “trailer park trash.” 


As the pandemic swept around the nation, Whisler persisted his cost-cutting tactics. Rather than paying for his or her house stadium’s cleansing features or paying extra for extra rooms to deal with social distancing, Whisler had his team of workers in finding fields in Wisconsin and Indiana for the groups to force to with a view to educate, in line with a supply as regards to crew operations. He used to be reluctant to make bigger the crew’s stadium operations from time to time, with one worker remembering an all-purpose room used for each garage and crew lifting, with repeated requests for higher exercise apparatus denied.

Despite each and every NWSL crew struggling vital losses within the 2020 pandemic yr, Chicago publicly took steps in early 2021 to check out to lend a hand steer the crew ahead. For the primary time in membership historical past, Whisler welcomed in a bunch of out of doors traders, ushering in what used to be meant to be a brand new generation of membership balance. In their introductory press convention, he admitted there used to be hobby within the crew as an entire, announcing he fielded “lowball” gives from the ones having a look to shop for a controlling stake. 

“We had people that were trying to steal the team,” Whisler stated. “You’d say they’re definitely trying to purchase the team for pennies on the dollar. Take control, do it their way.” He referenced a need to replace his personal attitudes because the league grew, admitting he had to evolve his personal mindset to compete with different golf equipment.

The NWSL flag waves in the wind during the match between the Kansas City Current and the Chicago Red Stars on Saturday, June 18, 2022 at Childrens Mercy Park in Kansas City, KS. (
(Photo via Nick Tre. Smith/Icon Sportswire by way of Getty Images)

Well-known names within the funding around integrated ESPN character Sarah Spain, former Chicago Bear Israel Idonije, and Team USA hockey participant Kendall Coyne Schofield, in addition to different behind-the-scenes leaders in each trade and leisure. As excited as the brand new workforce used to be to get entangled, they wanted a while to get acclimated with the ladies’s football area, and Whisler had promised to be their information. But, like Elby in 2018, what they discovered once they were given nearer to the crew stunned them. 

Some Red Stars used a meet-and-greet with new possession in August 2021 to return ahead with issues each about their housing scenarios—that have been described as having mould and water injury in an interior electronic mail reported via the Athletic—in addition to Dames’s training—which used to be described via gamers as “crossing the line,” in line with a supply provide. Alarmed via what they had been listening to, a bunch of the ones traders reached out to Whisler, who spoke back via mentioning SafeSport’s decision in 2019 that they didn’t have sufficient knowledge to do a complete investigation into Dames, which used to be referenced within the Yates document. Whisler insisted that the gamers’ housing used to be secure. 

As tales started to floor about managers at different NWSL golf equipment, gamers instructed an interior investigation be performed at the crew’s tradition, in line with the Yates document. The investigation did happen, described as performed via a “third-party sports psychologist and others,” via the crew. But the membership not on time motion till after the season used to be over, and the tradition assessment didn’t come with team of workers, in line with a former worker.

As for the verdict to let Dames stay training, Whisler informed the Chicago Tribune that it used to be about “allowing the players to finish the season that they wanted to finish.” According to the Yates document, the inner investigation confirmed that 70 % of gamers had proven indicators of emotionally abusive training, despite the fact that a loophole within the league’s anti-harassment coverage led to the retained sports activities psychologist to not give a proper advice for Dames’s firing, accepting a resignation as an alternative. None of this looked as if it would alternate Whisler’s steadfast trust that the Red Stars had been the nice guys, in line with a former worker.

According to another former worker, traders like Spain stored checking in with team of workers during the yr in some way that felt to them authentic and with out schedule. Chief trade officer Vicky Lynch additionally informed potential season price tag holders in February that she began attending away journeys with the crew in the midst of the season and losing in on practicing unannounced to check out to stay the surroundings secure. Simultaneously, the crew asked that each one questions requested of Dames in media availability stay soccer-focused handiest.

The Red Stars went on an not likely postseason run in 2021, profitable their quarterfinal and semifinal because the No. 4 seed to earn a place within the championship. That sport had the entire makings of a standard Red Stars efficiency, because the crew caught in combination within the face of COVID-19 quarantine uncertainty from famous person striker Mallory Pugh (on a timeline oddly obscured via Dames), a hamstring damage to captain Vanessa DiBernardo (now not discussed till she sat down in tears within the thirteenth minute), and a torn ACL for ahead Kealia Watt (by no means introduced). It used to be, for lack of a higher time period, a gritty efficiency in an time beyond regulation loss via a crew that had obviously bonded in combination via adversity.

Coming house tomorrow with out the trophy the crew had lengthy desired, the spin towards Dames’s deliberate resignation started in complete. According to an worker provide, Whisler referred to as an all-hands assembly to let team of workers know {that a} destructive tale can be popping out in the following few days, underselling the severity of it to deal with workplace morale. “‘Don’t believe everything you read,’ that type of thing,” they recalled. A unique former worker recalls being contacted to put in writing a “sensitive” press liberate that very same night time, in spite of not running for the crew. Whisler additionally then knowledgeable the investor workforce of Dames’s resignation, together with those that’d flagged issues about Dames months prior.

On Nov. 22, the crew stated in a liberate, “Under Rory’s leadership we have been a remarkably consistent and excellent club on the field. We continually evaluate our team and front office environment, and given the dynamic change underway in the league, it is time to begin the next chapter of the Red Stars with a search for new leadership of the team.” That commentary went unsigned, as did the crew’s followup commentary on Nov. 23 that learn partially, “There is no place for any type of abuse in women’s sports. The fact that it happened here, despite the belief that we had mechanisms in place to prevent it, means our club will require significant reflection and evaluation to ensure this does not happen again.”

This previous February, the Post revealed a 2d piece on Dames’s habits at Eclipse Youth Soccer, detailing sexual misconduct and an abusive training taste that dated again to the very beginnings of many gamers’ careers. The majestic plural of Red Stars possession lasted greater than 80 days. During that point, Whisler reverted to the way he’d all the time dropped at the crew—fixing issues in my opinion. 


Whisler reached out to make a choice native media for an off-the-record dialog inside per week of the primary Post tale, assuring them, “You haven’t misunderstood who I and my family are, and what the Red Stars are all about in this first 15 years.” That be offering used to be in the end grew to become down. He additionally despatched texts to Sam Johnson and Jen Hoy, two gamers who spoke on checklist, to factor the similar non-public apology, which Johnson described on her social media as “calculated.”

Frustrations persisted to boil over. Red Stars supporters workforce Chicago Local 134 launched a commentary on Twitter difficult Whisler promote his stocks of the membership. Whisler spoke back that he “would never condone, hide, or participate in abuse […] for 14 years we have worked with you and many to build this club. Your approach is hurting the club and staff.” He then held two personal conferences with supporters, each beneath the situation of complete confidentiality, responding to pre-screened questions. “Minority owners have been told we’re not allowed to speak on [Dames’s dismissal]. (We have and continue to demand access to agreements we’re allegedly beholden to but haven’t been shown),” Spain stated in a reaction to a query on Twitter.

In phrases of football operations, the next Red Stars offseason indicated that, once more, many gamers sought after out. The crew despatched defender Sarah Gorden to growth aspect Angel City FC upon request, in conjunction with the rights to Julie Ertz—injured within the 2021 common season opener, who by no means returned to marketplace post-injury.

Chicago additionally despatched two gamers to the San Diego Wave, in addition to midfielder Nikki Stanton to OL Reign. Their 2021 first-round draft pick out, Stanford ahead Madison Haley, by no means reported to the membership, they usually despatched their 2d pick out, Kelsey Turnbow, to San Diego. None of the ones offers integrated gamers coming to Chicago, and on the finish of the offseason the one participant got via the crew out of doors of the draft used to be the returning Nagasato, who has non-public ties to town. 

Whisler informed journalists in February that each one of the ones strikes got here from a need for extra taking part in time or a participant in need of to transport to a house marketplace—Gorden used to be born and raised in Chicago and performed each and every minute for the crew in 2021—and in addition that the group used to be pleased with getting gamers into new scenarios with out on the lookout for added price again. One former worker nonetheless shut with sure gamers painted a unique image, and stated even now some Red Stars are taking into consideration their futures with the membership due partially to the ongoing loss of aggressive salaries. 

Fans set a new attendance record for the Chicago Red Stars with 17,388 in attendance during the NWLS soccer game between Chicago Red Stars and North Carolina Courage at SeatGeek Stadium on July 21, 2019 in Bridgeview, Illinois.
Fans watch a sport between the Chicago Red Stars and the North Carolina Courage in 2019. (Photo via Daniela Porcelli/Getty Images)

A supply provide within the crew workplace in 2021 stated that team of workers had been inundated with offended conversations with lovers, whilst Whisler projected what they perceived as a savior advanced. 

“He’d talk about finding the joy and the pride in representing the Red Stars,” they stated, as workplace morale hit an rock bottom. 

With no transparent solution in sight, the tone from the membership modified. Whisler went public with each an open letter to lovers and restricted availability to a few media in early February. He then receded from public view for a time, despite the fact that he used to be provide at the discipline for Red Stars mainstay Alyssa Mautz’s retirement rite in July 2022, and he contributed a quote in a crew liberate as just lately as September.

Vicky Lynch, employed as CBO in April 2021, used to be by no means meant to run all of the franchise. She informed price tag holders that it took months for her to make bigger right into a player-facing position. That position abruptly additionally turned into public-facing, and she or he turned into a sounding board for media scrutiny, buyer members of the family, and as a participant liaison. The crew introduced a board of administrators in February 2022, increasing decision-making tasks and units of to be had eyes to a much wider workforce of possession, together with such things as participant housing. Lynch stated that, in the end, the membership had employed an HR director. 

A supply who has labored with Lynch within the Red Stars workplace described her as a businesswoman whose resúmé merits immense appreciate, however she lacked empathy from time to time and people-managing talents, which additional affected team of workers. 

“There were multiple instances last year where I think she came in very hot on people, and then realized that people are getting absolutely fed up,” they stated, describing interactions that they felt crossed the road into changing into dehumanizing. “Whether that was other supervisors talking to her, or there being a mass exodus of people in the middle of the season.” Lynch apologized to team of workers in an all-hands assembly early in 2022, in line with the similar supply. 

Another former worker described Lynch’s taste as “very fear-based,” and “not the right hire,” but additionally recalls receiving a private apology after leaving the membership. Two former staffers with wisdom of the location stated that there used to be a length later within the 2022 season during which Lynch used to be if truth be told in brief put on administrative go away whilst being internally investigated. 

When reached via Defector for remark, Lynch launched the next commentary: “As the Chief Business Officer of the Red Stars, in April 2021, I came into the role with high expectations for myself and the organization. The pre-existing, systemic challenges that I encountered were unexpected and significant. These challenges put tremendous stress on the staff and we all worked hard to do the best we could given the circumstances. In addition, while shifting my focus to support our players was the absolute right thing to do in order to ensure their safety, it inadvertently put more demands on the staff. I am hopeful that if the club can retain strong ownership and that the necessary resources are provided, the Red Stars can become the organization that the resilient players and staff deserve.”

Defector additionally requested the Chicago Red Stars for remark, in particular requesting touch upon if Lynch had ever been put on administrative go away. The crew didn’t reply to that query.

Publicly, Lynch informed media, “On my watch, there will be no reason for anybody to doubt this club,” and that she welcomed comments each from the investor workforce and lovers. In hiring the crew’s new trainer, Lynch stated {that a} committee of 9 participant volunteers, 3 assistant coaches, 3 house owners, Lynch herself, and affiliate basic supervisor Michelle Lomnicki made the overall resolution. New trainer Chris Petrucelli described the hiring procedure as essentially the most intense he’d ever been aware about, much more so than that of U.S. Soccer. 

The hiring seek dragged neatly into the 2021 preseason, with a supply as regards to one different candidate announcing they walked clear of the revel in feeling jilted via a loss of conversation. While stepping again from “day-to-day activities,” Whisler remained on the very height of the org chart till the Yates document used to be revealed, offering suggest and assets to Lynch when important. 

“He’d talk about finding the joy and the pride in representing the Red Stars,” they stated, as workplace morale hit an rock bottom. 

Team governance now runs via that board of administrators, made up of alternative house owners together with new chair Kim Vender Moffat, Dean Egerter, Abel Lezcano, Colleen Mares, Brian Walsh, and Kevin Willer. Whisler used to be got rid of from his position as chair of the board the day after the Yates document used to be revealed, and his loss of operational involvement used to be “codified,” in line with a crew liberate. Egerter has been an proprietor of the membership since 2007. However, on Tuesday The Athletic reported that the Board of Directors and minority possession who raised preliminary issues didn’t overlap. The identical day the board got rid of Whisler as chair, Spain tweeted, “Maybe one (any?) of my texts/emails will be answered and I’ll eventually know more than you do.”

On Oct. 10, Lynch introduced she had impulsively resigned from her place on the Red Stars. “I was sickened and felt that I had been misled about what had occurred at the club prior to my arrival,” she stated in a commentary. One former worker stated problem with Lynch, however stated they felt the managerial toxicity on the membership went a ways past its CBO. A unique former worker stated they consider she used to be doing the most productive she may just with the restricted assets she had, however admitted that she used to be “very hard” on her team of workers. They felt on the other hand that “being a bad manager doesn’t make you culpable for the larger issues in the club.”


In a ancient counterbalance to membership keep an eye on, the NWSL Players Association ratified the league’s first CBA on Jan. 31. Part of the narrative of 2022 has been the union protecting groups answerable for agreed-upon requirements; the Red Stars should stay up. On Monday, the NWSLPA introduced they’d additionally received in arbitration for gamers beneath a team-option contract to grow to be loose brokers subsequent season within the NWSL’s first ever free-agency length. For Chicago, that suggests gamers Vanessa DiBernardo, Danny Colaprico, Morgan Gautrat, Rachel Hill, and Arin Wright shall be in a position to enroll in different groups if they prefer.

The most up-to-date valuation of an NWSL membership got here out of a unique possession dispute with the Washington Spirit, through which an over-market be offering of $35 million used to be made and approved. Some as regards to the Red Stars ponder whether Whisler is looking ahead to that kind of payday earlier than stepping away. Even if there’s a compelled sale of the crew within the offing, it hasn’t introduced itself simply but, with U.S. Soccer abdicating actionable suggestions within the wake of the Yates document and a joint investigation between the NWSL and the NWSLPA later to return this yr.

On the sector, the strong Red Stars roster of years previous has grow to be a skilled workforce of long-term mainstays crammed out with draft selections and trialists, urged via a trainer and basic supervisor with unclear quantities of energy to put money into the crew’s long term. Despite shedding more than one defenders to long-term damage along with different absences because of maternity go away, the 2022 switch marketplace handiest produced younger Australian striker Chelsie Dawber, who used to be introduced in in April.

In 2021, the crew had a bit beneath one thousand season-ticket holders, a host now not out of line with smaller NWSL golf equipment, however nowhere close to the 15,000 season-ticket holder mark Los Angeles membership Angel City FC introduced in March. In 2022, out of doors of a doubleheader with the Fire at Soldier Field that the Red Stars had little or no hand in advertising and marketing, attendance has oscillated in Bridgeview, the place they averaged about 4,054 humans in attendance for 2022.

The crew’s efficiency this yr used to be a pleasing marvel, with various gamers previously sidelined via Dames proving in a position to main the crew and taking part in heavy mins, making the playoffs for the 7th immediately season. This yr’s tale at the discipline displays the previous in many ways, because the gamers navigated absence, damage, and extra to make town proud anyway. Now they’re looking to take a few of their energy again. As gamers stated of their collective commentary, they’re “committed to building a future in which players and staff alike can experience joy and success at our club.”

“You’re getting a glimpse into what the last few years have been like here in Chicago, and I’m proud of the veteran group for continuing to fight,” goalkeeper Alyssa Naeher informed journalists after Sunday night time’s playoff loss to the San Diego Wave. “You know, when I say fight, I mean on and off the field. And it takes a lot out of you. So to be able to still come in, show up every day and do your job and put in the work and fight for your teammates and fight for the person standing next to you. I think that’s what you saw this season. I think that’s what defined this group, is coming together on the field as players and fighting for each other.”

Elby, who held the presidency of the NWSL Players Association in her closing yr as a participant and is now graduated with a grasp’s level in trade management at Columbia University, summed up the location through which the crew unearths itself. On the only hand, the Red Stars are a staple of the NWSL, and the way may just any league now not have a crew in a town as huge and sports-obsessed as Chicago? On the opposite, alternate can’t include Whisler signing the tests.

“He’s clearly not doing a sufficient job if there’s this many problems in this short span of time,” Elby stated. “And I’m very thankful to him that he was part of the beginning of this league, but that doesn’t give you a pass for the rest of your life.”

Leave a Comment