Keith Law: MLB players I was wrong about, from Spencer Strider to Andrés Giménez

At the tip of each and every season, I take a look at players who’ve succeeded within the majors past the expectancies I had for them and provide an explanation for the place my projections for the ones players went wrong. Sometimes it’s what I noticed (or didn’t see), from time to time it’s an issue of incomplete knowledge from resources, however without reference to the explanations, they’re my errors, and it’s on me to be told from them to reinforce my projections for different players who may display similarities to those guys someday. Last yr, I wrote about only one participant, Austin Riley, going deeper into the large adjustments he made to his manner to pass from a sub-.300 OBP man to a viable MVP candidate. This yr, I’m returning to my outdated structure of figuring out a number of players who made considerable adjustments or in a different way crumpled up what I wrote about them and threw it within the wastebasket. Good for them, if now not for me.

The Guardians have returned to rivalry this yr thank you to a number of huge steps ahead from hitters of their mid-20s who had but to satisfy the expectancies laid on them after they have been possibilities. Amed Rosario is having his splendid season on the plate and within the box, with a three.5 WAR general that’s just about double what he was value a yr in the past. (He may just stand to take a stroll at times.) Josh Naylor got here into the season with 0.2 occupation WAR, and has been value a complete win this yr, just about doubling his occupation house run general and staying wholesome for many of the season. But no person at the roster has been as huge of a marvel as Andrés Giménez, who’s now sitting on 6.4 WAR, three hundred and sixty five days after he hit .218/.282/.351 and seemed like he may battle to cling a major-league activity.

Giménez made my best 100 simply as soon as as a prospect, touchdown at No. 97 sooner than the 2019 season, the place I praised his plus protection at shortstop and excellent baserunning, however wondered the bat: “At the plate, however, he doesn’t project to have much impact — at the very least, he has to get a lot stronger, and he doesn’t have the body or swing to ever be a big power guy.” That regarded correct till this yr, however Giménez has made a number of small adjustments that experience added up to a large spice up in each energy (16 homers) and high quality of touch.

Giménez’s hard-hit fee was below-average in 2020 at 26.4 p.c, and crept up to ok final yr at 30.4 p.c, nonetheless not anything to write house about. (Does one write house about hard-hit charges? Should I? You by no means name, you by no means write about hard-hit charges.) This yr he’s the entire approach up to 37.5 p.c, which quantities to 25 extra hard-hit balls this yr in line with his batted balls via Sunday’s video games. If I informed you a hitter may just convert one comfortable or medium-hit ball per week right into a hard-hit one, you’d take it, correct?

Keith Law: MLB players I was wrong about, from Spencer Strider to Andrés Giménez


Andrés Giménez (David Richard / USA Today)

He’s additionally stepped forward his manufacturing on offspeed stuff, particularly, quite oddly, on changeups, a pitch he’s destroyed this yr, hitting .400 on changeups with a .738 slugging share, with a hard-hit fee of 51 p.c on that pitch. He hit .160/.250 on changeups in 2021, for comparability. He’s now not hitting them extra steadily, but if he hits them, he hits them so much more difficult. To be truthful, I by no means noticed a subject matter with him hitting non-fastballs; I simply noticed a man who by no means hit the ball challenging, and didn’t have the swing to accomplish that.

Chris Valaika, the Guardians’ new hitting trainer, spoke concerning the small adjustments that experience made this sort of huge distinction for Giménez, particularly getting rid of his leg kick. “His big issue was getting on to that front side,” says Valaika. “We wanted to get him into a more consistent spot where he could use the ground. With the leg kick, he was losing the ground early. The results from that limited him, and he’d get those low top spinning singles.”

By eliminating the leg kick, Giménez now makes use of his decrease part extra to generate extra energy, and in addition comes on the ball from a reasonably decrease place to begin, so his attitude via touch is healthier — his common release attitude is up from 8.8 levels final yr to 12.8 this yr, and his charges within the optimum levels are up reasonably as smartly (e.g., between 26-30 levels, he’s up from 5.8 p.c final yr to 6.8 p.c this yr). I assume that’s a smaller a part of the equation than the best way he’s producing extra energy from his legs, regardless that; the swing is just a little other, however he’s long past from slapping the ball the use of simply upper-body energy to the use of his entire physique to force the ball, particularly to his pull aspect. The Guardians get a ton of credit score within the trade for the advance paintings they’ve accomplished at the pitching aspect, turning a number of command right-handers from faculty into above-average or higher big-league starters, however they’ve a name for buying much less from their hitting possibilities over the similar timespan. That may well be about to trade if their paintings with Giménez is any indication.

I first noticed Zac Gallen in spring coaching in 2017, 9 months after the Cardinals took him within the 1/3 spherical, and wrote: “he’s 90-93 with a cross-body delivery that probably makes it very hard for right-handed batters to see the ball against him, but there’s no plus pitch there and I don’t like cross-body deliveries on potential starters. If he doesn’t tidy that up, he’s a fairly high-risk guy for injury.” I wager I were given one phase correct, as Gallen has had some arm problems, particularly a UCL sprain in 2021, however he does have a plus pitch — his fastball.

Gallen is in a category of pitchers that I assume has been a blind spot for me through the years — command right-handers with ordinary-looking fastballs. Some have simply observed their pace reinforce after you have into professional ball, or with a brand new group. Shane Bieber is more than likely the most productive instance, as he was an average-velocity man in faculty with elite command for his age, after which Cleveland bumped up his velo and made him an ace.

Gallen’s four-seamer has been value 14 runs above common this yr, in accordance to Baseball Savant, even supposing he’s throwing it about part the time, so hitters without a doubt get their appears on the pitch. The pitch spins at a mean of 2420 rpm, placing him within the ninetieth percentile amongst four-seamers, and he will get each whiffs and susceptible touch at the pitch. It more than likely doesn’t harm that his pace at the four-seamer has crept up over 1 mph simply since 2019, even supposing I don’t assume that’s the name of the game of his luck or why I was so mild on him. Diamondbacks staff say he’s the most effective they’ve ever observed at getting ready for video games, studying hitters’ inclinations and figuring out pitch sequencing and tunneling to splendid make the most of the 4 pitches he has.

Arizona traded their best prospect on the time, shortstop Jazz Chisholm Jr., to get Gallen on the business time limit in 2019, a deal I panned as a result of I believed Chisholm can be a celeb and Gallen wouldn’t. Chisholm has performed like a celeb when wholesome and was on tempo for a 5-plus WAR season this yr when his season ended due to a pressure fracture in his again. But Gallen is the extra treasured participant at this time, and this business seems like a win-win somewhat than the straightforward victory for the Marlins that I concept it might be.

Spencer Strider was a part of the 2020 draft magnificence, taken within the fourth spherical by means of Atlanta as a result of he had an enormous fastball that performed in each and every approach, with pace, spin and motion. At the time, his breaking ball was nonetheless a query mark, however I wrote final offseason, when rating him as Atlanta’s Twelfth-best prospect (oops), that the slider may just finally end up plus. I additionally stated he’d want a 1/3 pitch to be a starter, however that hasn’t been the case in any respect this yr, as he’s steamrolled via right- and left-handed batters en path to what is going to more than likely be a Rookie of the Year-winning season.

Strider’s fastball has very a lot been as marketed; Baseball Savant has it because the third-most treasured four-seamer within the majors this yr, value 20 runs stored, at the back of handiest Justin Verlander’s and Carlos Rodón’s. Among starters, he has the seventh-best whiff fee at the pitch, forward of Verlander and necessarily tied with Rodón. And that every one comes even if Strider throws the four-seamer extra steadily than every other starter in MLB this yr: It accounts for 67 p.c of his pitches thrown, making him considered one of simply two starters who throws it greater than 62 p.c of the time along side Washington’s Joan Adon (65 p.c), apart from Adon’s fastball has been value 17 runs under common, so possibly he must check out the decaf.

Strider’s slider has turn into a plus pitch this yr, and that’s a large a part of his luck, however now not the place I was wrong on him. I stated he would wish a 3rd pitch to be ready to flip a lineup over a couple of instances, as a result of maximum fastball/breaking ball guys finally end up with massive platoon splits. Strider has a changeup nevertheless it’s an afterthought; he has handiest thrown it 8.4 p.c of the time this yr in opposition to lefties, throwing greater than 8 four-seamers for each and every changeup, even throwing the slider greater than two times as steadily to lefties as he does the changeup. It seems that it’s the slider that explains his luck in opposition to lefties, with a 22 p.c whiff fee. Left-handed batters have swung and overlooked on Strider’s slider 2.4 instances as steadily as they’ve put it into play.

In equity to the trade, Strider was most commonly unknown on the time of the 2020 draft; he’d overlooked 2019 after Tommy John surgical treatment, then threw simply 12 innings sooner than the pandemic ended the 2020 faculty season early. At the time, he was most commonly simply throwing fuel, and there have been a number of causes to assume he’d finally end up a reliever — the loss of a transparent 2nd pitch (let on my own a 3rd), the hot damage, a top stroll fee in his one complete season for Clemson. The construction of his slider right into a pitch that will get right- and left-handed batters out was a minimum of quite surprising, and Atlanta pros credit score him with the paintings he did final offseason to get the pitch to this level.


One extra fast notice on a participant I haven’t written anything else about since sooner than the 2019 season: I wrote in my Astros org. document that spring that Framber Valdez had the stuff to be an elite prospect, however now not the command or regulate. It took some time, however he were given there, reducing his stroll fee for the 1/3 directly yr (now not counting the abbreviated 2020 season), getting underneath 10 p.c for the primary time. I don’t assume I ever pushed aside this as a chance for Valdez, however I without a doubt didn’t assume it was even remotely most likely.

(Top picture of Strider: Dale Zanine / USA Today)

Leave a Comment